Project Contributions

Recent Contributions

Following

Reviews

  • Reviews - I-LAND
    cgwm808
    cgwm808

      1

    The premise of the show was interesting, to watch the development of young wannabees who are vying to be a B Band. But the method of choosing who will progress to a group which will be given an opportunity to debut is very bad as it pits each contestant against all others. The members vote to eliminate some to as many as half of the group on each episode. No criteria are set for voting. So a member might cast his vote against someone more talented than himself to increase his own opportunity to debut. Or vote for a good friend even though the friend may be less talented than everyone else. Even when the professionals choose the best performer, the best performer can choose one of the outcasts to stay in the group and thus doom someone else to replace the outcast. Without knowing who the outcast will be, the #1 performer unknowingly doomed the best dancer in the group who had perfected the #1 performer's dancing performance. Every single episode is more full of tears than joy for these young males who want so desperately to become idols. One can readily understand the stresses which cause young performers to commit suicide.

  • cgwm808
    cgwm808

      10

  • cgwm808
    cgwm808

      10